Hi Friends,
Today we are talking about the 2026 Goodreads Choice Awards, specifically the Mystery & Thriller category. I’m giving you my predictions on which book I think is going to win and some of the other top contenders nominated. I haven’t read any of these books because, sadly, my reading this year has been very slow!

First up, we have Dear Debbie by Freida McFadden. She is a very, very popular author and usually has one of her books make it into the top five of the awards. Speaking of Freida, The Witch is also nominated, which I’ve heard is her first paranormal thriller. So, I will admit that it has piqued my interest.
Then we have This Story Might Save Your Life by Tiffany Crum. I believe this was a Book of the Month pick, and I think it’s about a podcaster whose podcasting co-host goes missing. Something along those lines!
Next, we have Her Last Breath by Taylor Adams. I know Taylor Adams is a very popular author, but I haven’t heard much about this particular book. Also, the one book by Taylor Adams that I tried to read was unfortunately a DNF for me.

We also have Anatomy of an Alibi by Ashley Elston. I really loved her book First Lie Wins, and I’ve read other books by her as well, so I really want to read this one. I just haven’t gotten around to it yet. We also have My Husband’s Wife by Alice Feeney, which I have an ARC of but have yet to read. However, I’ve heard nothing but good things about this book. I’ve read many Alice Feeney books, and they are always such quick reads.
Related Post: First Lie Wins | Book Review
The Anniversary by Alex Finlay was a book I was a bit surprised to see on this list. I really enjoy Alex Finlay’s books, but I don’t feel like many people talk about them. I do believe my favorite book by him, The Night Shift, was nominated for a Goodreads Choice Award the year it was released, so I guess seeing another one of his books make the list shouldn’t come as that much of a shock to me. Also nominated is It’s Not Her by Mary Kubica. I tried reading one of her books, but everything from the writing style to the plot just wasn’t for me.
Related Post: The Night Shift | Book Review

Then there’s It Could Have Been Her by Lisa Jewell on the list. I haven’t heard a lot of people talking about this book, and I didn’t even realize she had released a new book until about a month ago! We also have Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel by Lucy Foley, which is Lucy Foley’s Agatha Christie-inspired novel, as well as The Unknown by Riley Sager
Related Post: None Of This Is True | Book Review
There are some other nominees in this category, but those are the ones I’m most familiar with. Personally, I think The Witch by Freida McFadden could take the award because she is such a popular author and so many people love her work. Even though I don’t love all of her books, I’ve only read The Housemaid series, and I liked the first book but not so much the others. I actually DNFed the third book in the series.
Related Post: The Housemaid | Book Review<
However, I think The Unknown by Riley Sager will win! Not only is Riley Sager very popular and has won the Goodreads Choice Awards in the past, but this book has also been pretty successful, receiving mostly positive reviews. So, he might just take home the win!
Related Post: The Only One Left | Book Review
So, those are my predictions for the Mystery & Thriller category. Let me know if you’ve read any of the books in this category, who you’re voting for, and who you hope wins! Also, make sure to check out my other Goodreads Choice Awards prediction posts. Come back after Round One voting ends and Round Two begins because I’ll be doing an updated predictions post to let you know if my predictions have changed. So, to make sure you don’t miss that post or any future posts, sign up for my mailing list!
Until The Next Chapter.
Bunny
All book synopses are sourced from Amazon or Goodreads.
This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission—at no extra cost to you—if you purchase through my links. Thank you for supporting my cozy little corner of the internet!
